“My dear Watson, how does one go about kissing a woman?”
My friend, Mr. Sherlock Holmes, seemed deadly serious.
"You're joking, old man. You don't know how to give a
woman a kiss?" I stared at him. I’d never expected such
a revelation.
"It's hardly been an area of pressing study." He arched
a brow, indicating I should have known better than to
make such a statement. I’d not applied his methods of
deduction and reasoning in a manner that suited him. Not
for the first time. Nor doubtless for the last.
The spring of 1896 marked a wealth of fresh cases for my
friend. His fame had grown to such an extent requests
came from all quarters, our morning mail littered with
missives bearing crests and seals from all over Europe
and the empire. Most were refused. Wealth and title in a
client meant nothing to Holmes. The lowest street
sweeper’s problem had as much chance of peaking his
interest as that of a king. I often thought a lowly
person actually had more of a chance, for my friend had
no great fondness for the arrogance of entitlement.
So I found some with some surprise then an invitation
for me to join him at the estate of the Viscount
Toddington as soon as I might be able to do so. In his
usual fashion, he’d telegrammed me. It lay for two days,
waiting my return to the Baker Street rooms I’d so long
shared with Holmes from an extended trip into
Northumberland. I’d not heard a word from him in the
over two weeks I’d been gone.
Before I’d left Baker Street, Holmes had been deeply
involved in a case, forsaking our rooms in the pursuit
of clues. I’d seen little of him, hearing him come in
late at night and leave before I arose in the morning.
In the midst of this, a friend from my army days
requested I come down to his country place and give my
opinion on his young wife’s aliment. Though I doubted I
could do any more than the excellent physician he’d
already engaged, I’d gone for the sake of a friend in
distress.
Sadly, my prediction had proven correct and I’d been
forced to agree with my colleague’s diagnosis of
tuberculosis. Nothing would do my friend but that I must
stay and help map out a course of treatment and advise
on a plan of relocation to a healthier climate. All in
all, it had been nearly a fortnight since I’d left
London, and twice that since I had any meaningful
conversation with Holmes. It struck me as odd that the
telegram asking me to come down to the borders of the
great Weald, that remnant of the ancient forest once
covering our fair isle, had waited two days for my
arrival. Holmes knew my direction and could has easily
have sent his message to Northumberland.
Still, a call from Holmes was a call from Holmes and
indicated his need of my services and companionship. I
seldom refused him either. So it was that, without
bothering to unpack, I found myself on a train to the
Vale of Holmesdale at the foot of the North Downs of
Surrey. The dismal rain of grey London didn’t dim the
bright new green of an English springtime countryside.
Indeed, intermittent breaks in the clouds allowed the
sun to set the world aglitter, swaths of bright flowers
showing on the hillsides and pastures. As my train
rolled through the awakening landscape, the bursts of
sunshine grew more frequent and the sadness of a lovely
young woman ill with an incurable ailment lifted a bit
from my soul. My earlier inclination to brood over the
unfairness of fate vanished and a keen desire to aid
Holmes in whatever drew him into the glory of our
verdant island grew in my heart.
Such was my mood as the Guildford-Redhill Line delivered
me to Shere, a quaint and quintessential Surrey village
some five or six miles from the larger town of Gomshall.
A collection of several old houses and shops, a church,
a smithy, and pair of pubs made it the center of local
life. The Tillingborne, a small stream, ran through the
middle of the tiny hamlet, rendering it an attractive
and altogether pleasing spot.
I stepped off the train into sunlit mist and the clean
scent of rain-washed greenery. Holmes waited for me at
the station, a faint smile on his lean face. He clasped
my hand in warm welcome and consigned my bags to the
care of a dark and rather gloomy man in the dress of a
coachman. Holmes indicated this individual would convey
my baggage to Toddington Oaks in the trap while we would
take advantage of the end of the showers by enjoying the
fine afternoon and walk there. I found his suggestion
very much to my liking. This lovely place would chase
the last of the wet chill of Northumberland from my
soul.
I waited until the taciturn worthy rattled out of the
station in his black trap before turning to Holmes and
asking why he’d asked me to so out-of-the-way though
picturesque a spot.
“I need a best man, Watson.” He started off through the
village, grey coat buttoned against the crisp spring
air. “I’m to be married in a week.”
“Married!” The shock of it stopped my pace in the midst
of the street. “Holmes, I’ve only been gone a
fortnight.” A rather uncomfortable memory seized me.
“This isn’t another charade in the name of a case, is
it? I do hope you’re not once again toying with some
poor girl’s affections only to stomp on her
sensibilities once you’ve got your man. Really, Holmes,
it’s not worthy of you at all.”
“Oh no, not at all.” He took my arm and we began to walk
again, the gurgling stream pacing us. “The lady is well
aware that I am Mr. Sherlock Holmes of 221B Baker
Street. In fact, she’s quite fond of those little
flights of romantic fancy you publish. I daresay you’ll
be asked for an autograph at the very least.” The few
houses fell away as he led me along the narrow lane at
an energetic pace. “I have been courted and won by Miss
Winnifred Farnham of Toddington Oaks, the most fair
granddaughter of a duke and an earl, renowned throughout
the land for her beauty and her headstrong nature.”
Her name was vaguely familiar to me, though I recalled
little more than the usual pursuits of a young and
wealthy girl. I also recalled some mention of her
comeliness. Not that any of that would matter to Holmes.
From the qualities he’d just listed, she certainly
didn’t sound like the sort of woman who could woo and
win him. I’d not thought a woman existed who could have,
not even the enigmatic Irene Adler for all her bravery
and blinding wits. So surely not the headstrong daughter
of ruling class nobility some fifteen or more years his
junior. It simply did not make sense.
I tried to reason has he’d taught me. The problem was I
lacked data, a state of affairs he’d often bemoaned
himself. I considered him from the corner of my eye. A
faint smile graced his thin, mobile mouth. A spark
lurked deep under the heavy lids of his grey eyes. His
whole being exuded a sense of restrained joy. Only one
thing brought that sort of elation to my friend. “This
does have something to do with a case, though, doesn’t
it? I know of nothing else that would bring you to
Surrey. You hate holiday.”
“It began with a case, yes.” He kept our stride quite
brisk. “A rather delicate and serious one, of great
concern to Whitehall. The crime, my dear Watson, is
espionage.” No one should look quite that pleased over
so terrible a crime. I was long inured to Holmes’ rather
inappropriate glee in such things, though.
“Espionage? Well, that explains a little. But way out
here?” The village fell away, dropping behind us as we
entered a section of very pretty roadway bordered on one
side by a massive holly oak hedge and on the other by a
great stretch of forested parkland.
“The country is not immune to dark intrigues, Watson.
I’ve often remarked on that to you.” He swept up the
bucolic prospect about us in a wave of his arm. “What
better place to pass along information? You may invite
only those you wish to have about you. A stranger will
be noted immediately. There is far less chance of the
the police or an agent in disguise spying on you. The
country is always ripe for crime.”
“And how in heaven’s name did a case of espionage lead
to you...being courted?” I tried my best to not seem too
shocked, as I had no wish to hurt Holmes’ feelings if
this truly were genuine. “Forgive me, old friend, but I
simply cannot imagine you swept off your feet by love.
You’ve said yourself women are not to be trusted, even
the best of them.”
“I’ve not said I trust Winnifred.”
That sentiment didn’t surprise me either, though it
saddened me. I never expected Holmes to marry, but if
such was his intent, then so cynical and nearly
cold-blooded a stance regarding his wife wasn’t
shocking. I already felt great sympathy for the unknown
Winnifred. Life with Holmes could be a thing of great
joy—save on those occasions when it was utterly hellish.
We turned from the main road onto a footpath leading
through the park. Great trees, ancient and mossy,
surrounded us. Shafts of sunlight pierced their leafy
canopy, bright on the mist swirling about their great
trunks.
“Really, Holmes. That’s hardly the proper attitude to
take toward one with whom you intend to spend your
life.”
Holmes employed his walking stick to great emphasis.
“Nonsense. It’s perfectly rational. I do however, trust
her more than her half-brother, Robert Adair Chilton,
Viscount of Stepney. My investigations have led me to
that worthy. I believe he has developed a web of
informants who provide him with tidbits that, while
meaningless in themselves, can be put with other tidbits
to form a whole that would be valuable to those outside
the empire. Oh, it takes a keen mind to place all the
puzzle pieces together, but it can be done. Witness
brother Mycroft. What I cannot lay my hand on is proof
of this and how this Lord Stepney communicates his
findings to his buyers.”
“So you met Miss Farnham in the course of your
investigation.” There was something he hadn’t told me.
Either he couldn’t, because of the case, or he was
waiting for me to figure it out on my own. “And
she...caught your attention?”
“More a matter of forced my notice.” A faint smile
played about his lips. “As I rather expected her to. In
the course of investigating Lord Stepney, I found that
it is a widely known fact his sister is more than
enamored with your scribblings, old man. So much so, it
borders on the fanatical. I daresay you might have a
letter or two from her in that bag your publisher sends
over monthly. I reasoned that if I presented myself in a
place where the lady might be, the rest would follow
suit. And it did. Mycroft procured an invitation to an
afternoon soiree and the rest, as the saying goes, was
history. The lady finagled an introduction within five
minutes of discovering my presence and has seldom been
more than a footstep away since.”
The visual that presented left me quelling a smile of my
own. “I am sorry, Holmes. I had no intention of turning
you into a spectacle. But how did you get from having an
adoring shadow to engagement?”
“Winifred considered me a challenge. You see, she’s of a
very forceful character and there is nothing more
appealing to her than something she can’t have. I well
remember her first words to me. ‘Doctor Watson says you
don’t care for women. Well, I dare say I could make you
care for me.’ I will admit it had a unique, if brash,
quality.”
Now things started to make sense. I could well imagine
such a direct, almost masculine approach to courtship
appealing to Holmes. No pretenses, no girlish games. A
simple statement of intent. I chuckled. “With such a
force in pursuit, I’m surprised she hasn’t taken it upon
herself to kiss you first.”
“Oh, she has. I just haven’t reciprocated. I have,
instead, lectured her on the proper behavior of a young
English noblewoman upon finding herself alone with a
gentleman.” A smile twitched his lips. “Winnie—for so
she insists I call her—finds me a horrid stick in the
mud and not nearly as much fun as I should, or indeed
could, be. She has therefore issued an ultimatum. I
must prove to her my manly prowess in the arts of
physical love at the very next opportunity or she’ll
have none of me.”
“Then why are you marrying her?” I confess I was
hard-pressed not to laugh at his matter-of-fact
narrative.
“Aside from her traitorous brother, she really is the
most fascinating creature. She’s possessed of a truly
startling beauty. The more besotted of her admirers
write poems to her wealth of pale gold hair and
cornflower eyes, to her milky skin and dainty form. Yet
for all her delicacy of body, there is not a single bit
of such in her personality. She has none of the die-away
airs you’d expect of so frail a beauty. In fact, she’s
in all ways a very modern girl and feels herself up to
any exploit a man might tackle. She uses neither tricks
nor subterfuge, but rather her own very forceful
personality to achieve her ends. Witness our engagement.
I was quite startled by her proposal.”
“Oh, do tell!” I stopped beneath the deep shade of an
enormous oak tree, easily the oldest one directly around
us. A carved stone bench sat among ferns and intense
blue flowers opposite it. A break in the forest allowed
for a view of the valley. Great stretches of grassy
knolls and swaths of mighty trees swept down to a ribbon
of water, glittering in the fitful sunlight. Faint
trails of smoke marked homesteads and hamlets. “Holmes,
you cannot just stroll along here spinning a narrative
of such interest without giving me some details.”
“What more do you need? I assured we would meet, knowing
the lady would pursue me. She did. She, however, proved
a bit more than I expected.” That little smile appeared
again. “I’d honestly thought to gain entrance to her
parents’ household and little more. From there, I could
observe her brother more closely, see what his habits
are, see who he spoke with. Winnie rather altered those
plans. I gained my entrance, but not in the way I
expected. Her pursuit was the most vigorous and the most
straightforward I’ve ever heard of. I’ve found myself
quite bowled over by it.”
“I see.” I could not imagine such a woman putting up
with Holmes’ erratic schedule, nor having me around at
all hours. A strange knot formed in the pit of my
stomach, but I refused to let Holmes see my distress and
instead clapped him on the shoulder, forcing a smile to
my lips. “Well, then, congratulations are in order. Well
done, old chap. I’d be honored to stand as your best
man.”
“True as ever, my dear fellow. However, that may not be
necessary if I can’t come up to Winnie’s exacting
standards in the art of kissing.” A watery sunbeam found
a path through the dense leaves above us, settling about
Holmes head and shoulders, haloing him in softest gilt.
He faced me with the oddest mixture of wry amusement and
chagrin. “My dear Watson, how does one go about kissing
a woman?”
"You're joking, old man. You don't know how to give a
woman a kiss?" I could not countenance such a thing. For
all his misogyny, surely, at some point in his life he’d
had congress with a woman, at least enough to exchange a
kiss.
"It's hardly been an area of pressing study."
I didn’t doubt the truth of that. Unless it aided his
pursuit of deductive reasoning and criminal
investigation, it held no interest for him. Still...
“Surely, at some point in your career, in your disguises
among the lower elements if nothing else, you’ve been
forced to...ahm...consort with a certain class of
woman?” I hadn’t intended it as a question, but his
raised brows rendered it such.
“I have always endeavored to avoid intimate dealing with
prostitutes, Watson. Filth and disease hold no
attractions for me whatsoever.” The term forbidding was
the mildest I could think of to describe his tone and
expression. Then both lightened and faint smile
appeared. “In any case, one does not kiss whores, old
man. It just isn’t done.”
I started to speak, rethought the advisability of it,
and simply shook my head instead. A multitude of things
kept life with Holmes of more than ordinary interest.
“Unlike you, dear friend, I am no charmer of the fair
sex. I normally leave such matters firmly in your expert
hands. Flower seller or duchess, they all find you of
the greatest attraction. I’ve none of your considerable
experience, though.” He sighed. “I need a teacher,
Watson. And quickly, for I expect Winnie to corner me
when I return to the house.”
So walking back rather than taking the carriage had
other motives than just enjoying the day and the
beautiful scenery. I could sympathize with Holmes; I
would not wish to be a man under the glass of the woman
he’d described. "Well, in the interest of rescuing you
from banishment, I suppose I could give you a lesson."
"A lesson?" Holmes' rather contemplative expression
gained a flash of smirk at the corners of his lips. "I
had no idea you cared so very much for my happiness,
though I had rather hoped you might. You’ve offered to
make a great sacrifice, old man."
"I’ve always cared about your happiness and your
well-being. Heaven knows I’ve hounded you enough about
those awful stimulants." I laid a hand on his shoulder
and steeled myself for what I must say. “It’s hardly a
sacrifice to help you win the regard of the woman who’s
captured your fancy at last.” I still couldn’t quite
grasp that concept. Holmes, married. In love. No longer
in need of my help or companionship. I pushed the
unworthy thought away as best I could.
"Indeed." His shoulders lifted and hunched in a swift
motion under my hand. "You’ve ever stood my friend. But
how, pray tell, you do you plan to teach me the fine art
of kissing a woman when there are no women presently
around and I have severe doubts that my intended would
tolerate her lady’s maid—who seems to have a fondness
for me as well—filling in." The sun lit his eyes,
sparkling on the surface, the deeper layers hidden. I
wonder if anyone, even I who knew him so well, could
ever plunge all their depths. Amusement reflected from
their surface. “I’ve little doubt she’d toss us all in
the courtyard fountain.”
I ignored the small cramp in my middle and focused on
his request. "It's quite simple, Holmes. We'll have to
use a substitute." Surely it couldn't be that hard to
come up with some sort of idea. If the odd
breathlessness would leave me, I’ve no doubt I could.
“Hmm...well. There are several smaller trees around
here. You’ve a vast gift for seeing beyond what the rest
of us do. Simply imagine the tree is your intended.” I
managed to speak the last word over the growing knot in
my stomach.
He stared at me for a long moment, then his left brow
climbed. “A tree.” The brow slowly lowered. He sank onto
the stone bench, hands clasped over the silver head of
his cane, so he could glare up at me. “Really, Watson.”
“Well I can hardly suggest one of the neighborhood
cows.” Of all his tones, the one insisting I was the
village idiot always irritated me more than any other.
In the present state of my nerves, it rankled even more.
“And since I know you well enough not to even suggest a
verbal description alone, what do you recommend, out
here in the middle of nowhere?”
“Whatever it might be, I’m certain it would be more
useful than that of a tree or a cow.” He drew himself
very erect, his gaze out among the ferns. “I see that
extended visits to the country are not salubrious to
your thought processes. You should remain in town where
the hubbub can stimulate your brain.” He cast me a look
of utter disdain from low-lidded eyes. “A tree.”
“Fine.” Of all the maddening, annoying, obstinate men
ever born! “You want a lesson, fine.” I rested one
knee on the bench, caught him by the nape of the neck
and crushed my mouth down onto his, my exasperation with
him overcoming all else.